Simon Says So Long Acheron


You know, of all the insane events, celebrity deaths (fucking Phife Dawg, man.), and political clusterfucks (LofuckingL at Great Britain) that have made up the blueprint of 2016 thus far, this one is right up there as the most soul crushing.

Just about a week ago, the owners of famed NYC venue The Acheron posted this on their Facebook page.

It is with a profoundly heavy heart that we have to announce July 9th will be the last show at the Acheron. As a result of numerous factors that are completely out of our control, the space can no longer be used for shows. The Anchored Inn will remain open, doing the glorious work of keeping the punks fed and drunk. We are endlessly grateful to all of our staff, along with (almost) every band and show-goer that has ever walked through these doors. When we started 6 years ago I don’t think any of us imagined the Acheron would have grown into what it is now, and we feel very proud of all that we accomplished in that time. It has been a pleasure, and we mean that from the bottom of our hearts.
We are working on a few last minute shows to finish up our final weeks and will announce them as soon as we can.

All shows booked for after the 9th will be moved to new venues, which we will also announce soon.

Thank you to everyone that helped make this feel more than just a venue over the years. While we’re all deeply saddened by the loss, we feel extremely proud, and privileged to have been able to do this for as long as we have. Please come find us at the bar, and let’s have a drink. Viva 57!

What did Janet Jackson used to say? “Don’t know what you got till it’s gone.” Bet she wasn’t saying that shit about Jermaine Dupri. But in all seriousness, this hurts. A lot. While there are many other venues in this hellforsaken city that have had many other great shows, this little bar with a very small space wedged right next to it located on Waterbury St. just a couple of blocks south of the L train, a school, and an conclave of abandoned warehouses was a very beloved cornerstone of the NYC metal scene.

I had been around when the names of La’mours, the original Knitting Factory, and CBGBs were whispered with reverence from many a metal-head and punks lips, and had attended many shows in those places. But The Acheron I believe was something special that deserved just as much love. I’m not going to bore you with history or go on a diatribe about all the people whose lives the venue changed, citizens. Instead I will just share two beloved memories of my own.

The first show I attended there was Abnormality opening up for Malignancy. They were on tour for Contaminating the Hive Mind and I absolutely had to catch their first NY show ever and watch Malika and co. tear shit up. They killed it of course, but one of the memories that forever sticks out of my rotting brain from that show was of two concertgoers of the fairer sex getting very angry at Malignancy, proceeding to toss their cups of whatever beverage they were imbibing at them and storm out of the place. The band then proceeded to adjust the jokes and banter they had been firing at the ravenous audience in between their 3 minute spastic deathgrind onslaughts to include how ridiculous such a random scenario was. I don’t know why they were angry, and apparently neither did the band. But whatever argument you could apply towards the treatment of two females at a metal show, which I personally won’t go into here because it wasn’t the point I was trying to make, the whole scene made for an inescapable memory within this maniac’s head. The rest of their set absolutely crushed though, so there’s that.

Memory # 2 would be Sadistic Intent, Deathhammer and a couple of other bands two years ago. After I finished off possibly the best burger I’ve ever eaten, some of the bar’s infamous fries, and a nice bottle of summer pale ale, it was time for the event. Local trad metal riffers Natur, who played seemingly every underground show back then, opened and killed as usual. But neither they nor other openers Iron Force could prepare me for the absolute spine-altering assault of the two main bands. Those four madmen of Deathhammer trekked all the way from Sweden to engulf everyone in a shitstorm of thrash riffs in the first of two times I would see them in the next two years. And I’ll tell ya citizens, “Full Moon Sorcery” in particular is a goddamn revelation live. And then Sadistic Intent took the stage. From the intro of “Impending Doom,” they launch into “Asphyxiation” and for the next hour or so, they have the audience of denim and black shirt clad folks in the palm of their weathered riff weaving hands. Here, there was no talk of inclusion or safe space, because that audience and that band at that very moment, THAT was the damn safe space; everyone there was as one, connected through the riffs and the throng of swirling bloody beer stained bodies.

By the time Sadistic Intent closed off their set with Funerals Obscure and I said goodbye to my buddies and departed for home downing my last PBR (shut up), I felt it. That incomprehensible sense of awe and serenity that only a really good set from a band you like, or a band that MADE you like them through sheer force of will, can provide. One can get this feeling at any show at any venue depending on the band and so forth, but only a small venue can conjure up that combination of intimacy and energy and, along with its “big brother” St. Vitus, The Acheron was cream of the crop for this in the greater NY area.

I’m sure there will be other venues and bars and clubs that will open up in the wake of the few months after The Acheron closes its doors for good as a music venue on July 9th (The Anchored Inn bar next door will remain open). But to this maniac at least, while those places will put on many good shows, it won’t quite feel the same. Take heed of this citizens and support your local goddamn scene and venues. Don’t let this happen to you. And for any NY metal-heads out there, try to go the last show on the 9th featuring Magrudergrind, Trenchgrinder, and a couple of other rad bands. Give the Acheron a last great hurrah.

Acheron, I will burn a police station or two in your honor. Thanks for the cheap craft beer and the crushing riffs you provided me and the rest of the NY metal scene over the years. VIVA 57.

Post via Cover pic via

Did you dig this? Take a second to support Toilet ov Hell on Patreon!
  • Damn, that sucks dude. Some good times went on there it looks.

    Here’s my favorite Sadistic Intent song…

  • CyberneticOrganism

    Sounds like a damn cool place, sucks that it’s gotta go. Nothing beats a giant burger and pale ale before a concert.

  • Quality venues closing is one of the saddest damn things ever.

  • I have been to the Acheron twice. 1st time was for Rotten Sound who absolutely destroyed. There was also a crust punk band from Austrailia whose name escapes me. Their singer was crowd surfing the entire time broke a mic. Sound manbro was not pleased with him. Second trip was for Cult Leader, Secret Cutter and The Banner. Edward is jelly of that one.

  • Magrudergrind starts at midnight. That’s too late of a start time for my old ass.

  • Lacertilian

    Bummer, man.

  • Stanley

    There are a few venues in SF that have closed over the years, but what is more disappointing is that the one that I like going to the most (Slim’s) doesn’t have many metal shows any more (except for Death Angel). Luckily DNA Lounge has picked up some of the slack, but mostly I see bands playing in Oakland now. The larger venues still have metal but it’s mostly the bands that I don’t want to see. Support your small local venues folks. Keep underground metal alive!

  • Stanley

    Regarding your comment about the GB “Clusterfuck”, only time will tell. Most of the media has focused on fear mongering to convince the British people to stay in the EU, and it obviously backfired. For anyone that is interested, here is an excellent and eloquently delivered debate at Oxford University from a British MEP (member of the european parliament) that would LIKE to be voted out of a job. It’s quite compelling.

    • Abradolf Lincler

      stocks in the US have already started rebounding. the fearmongering is real. all of that is to try and fear the other EU pillars (France/Germany) from uprising, too.

      • That’s not how financial markets work. Stocks don’t rise and fall with people trying to scare others. It goes down to the individual investor’s confidence in future changes.

        • Abradolf Lincler

          and apparently, the UK leaving only changed investor confidence for < 1 wk

          • Yeah. There was a sharp short term loss that may or may not continue in the future. You can’t look at a week’s worth of data and make a conclusion on what will happen next. But for a lot of people that sharp drop lost them a fuck ton of money. My investments took a decent sized shit.

          • Abradolf Lincler

            so did my 401k. though you took one statement i made that i was saying was symptomatic of the brexot vote. what i was actually talking about was the global fearmongering to keep France/Germany from doing the same thing the UK did.

    • I agree with you, I don’t think anyone can say for sure what the impact of this will be down the road. Everyone has a crystal ball now and thinks they know how things will shake out. Fact of the matter is, they don’t.

      • Stanley

        The only thing that people now for sure is that it’s going to be a very, very messy split.

        • Grandpa’s Magic Fleshlight

          And a very long road to recovery. In literally the first two hours alone, they lost over 10% of their GDP and ended up costing investors over $2 trillion. Whether they’ll continue to bleed money like this down the road is anyone’s guess, but they’ll have quite a while trying to make it back, especially since dicking the investors that quickly and recklessly.

          • Dave Vincent’s Perm

            The pound is coming back up. Personally I think it would have gone down whether we voted to stay in or leave, but really my opinion is meaningless.

    • Grandpa’s Magic Fleshlight

      There’s been a lot of talk about doing the vote all over again, which I think would turn out quite differently. Plus there’s a clause in the EU contract (Amendment 50, IIRC) that can actually keep Britain in there. I doubt they’ll invoke it, but it’s possible.

      • Stanley

        There’ll be no revote. This is democracy. Article 50 is what GB needs to invoke to start the exit process (not the other way around). GB is saying that they will not start the process until a new leader is place (September/October timeframe). After invoking the article it is supposed to take two years to complete the exit but most economists think it will take ten.

        • Grandpa’s Magic Fleshlight


  • Losing a beloved venue is a pain like no other. Sorry to all the nyc friends who are losing the acheron

    • Margaretjsanchez2


  • Dubbbz

    Sorry to hear about this closure. Sounds like a rad place.

  • brokensnow

    Yeah, lost or favorite venue. its a cheap strip club now. Lost the carriage house and Peabodys one year after the other. good venues are few and far between in NE Ohio.

    • Sight Vnseen

      Fuck. Peabodys still hurts.

    • Grandpa’s Magic Fleshlight

      I heard a lot about Peabody’s when I was living in Cinci, but never got to go. Been to Bogart’s, though.

  • Pentagram Sam

    Damn man, I’m all the way out in TX, but even I have heard people talk about the Acheron in a similar way they did with LaMours. Will it remain a club at all or is it just gonna be a sports bar or something assy like that?

    In San Antonio The White Rabbit was an equivalent of something like this, sorta-ish. Saw a shitload of bands there between 2005 -2010 and now it’s some lame ass bar. There’s some other new and actually nice clubs that opened up, but The White Rabbit had it’s own cool ass vibe and feel.

    • From the sound of things, it appears the venue will be turned into something else. The good thing about the NYC area is that another spot always seems to pop up and fill the void created by a venue closing down.

      • Grandpa’s Magic Fleshlight

        Weren’t they supposed to reopen CBGBs about a year or so ago? I heard something that the original owner gave control of it to his kids, and was supposed to become either a music venue again, or gift shop (GAH!).

        • I didn’t hear that, but I doubt something like that would happen.

  • Señor Jefe El Rosa

    This was great Simon, thanks for writing it! Sounds to me like it was quite the venue and lots of fun.

  • Waynecro

    Nice write-up! Thanks for sharing your awesome experiences. My condolences.

  • Grandpa’s Magic Fleshlight

    Heard the place mentioned many many times, but not quite familiar with it’s history. I’m guessing that they were priced out of the place (aka, the landlords jacking up the rent), which kills off venues more so than low attendance. Sucks, either which way!